#
…

2026-10-12

00:32ralim8 has quit [Quit: The Lounge - https://thelounge.chat]
00:32ralim8 has joined #asahi-dev
00:33BumbleBottom[m] has joined #asahi-dev
00:50bennofs3 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
00:56bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
01:07iwuvmika has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
01:42bennofs3 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
01:44iwuvmika has joined #asahi-dev
01:48bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
02:00yurix has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
02:00yurix has joined #asahi-dev
03:12Shining[m] has joined #asahi-dev
03:18marvin24 has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
03:26iwuvmika has quit [Read error: No route to host]
03:31iwuvmika has joined #asahi-dev
03:34nora_ has joined #asahi-dev
03:36nora has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
03:58MichaelReeves[m]i was bored so I made a mockup of what the GUI installer might look like. cause I think before anyone does any coding, so there's not wasted work, we should agree on the design.
03:58MichaelReeves[m]its rly bad but I guess we have to start somewhere and feedback (from anyone) is much appreciated! https://drive.google.com/file/d/1vvtBx8XapoCtCyxDItjiKgXQZU8awX9q/view
03:58MichaelReeves[m]if you want to be shared into the canva LMK
04:00MichaelReeves[m]also btw yuka did you get around to testing the SEIS erratum on M4? just so I know if I can send v2 yet or not
04:13JamesCalligeros[m]the colours are a bit busy and the scaling needs some work of course
04:13JamesCalligeros[m]i would probably also replace the giant kde vs gnome buttons with a list widget that enumerates all options and has a screenshot somewhere else on the page for relevant options
04:36MichaelReeves[m]the idea behind hiding sever and UEFI under “other options” was so ppl who don’t know what they’re doing wouldn’t get confused and press it but maybe it’s just better to have a simpler list and the. “DEs” and “advanced” section
04:36MichaelReeves[m]s/sever/server
04:44nickchanthere's also the issue of stage2 installer design
04:45nickchan(I think that should be GUI as well, yes)
04:45nickchanwith the limiations of recovery that probably should vaguely look like the macOS installer
04:46nickchanwith a stage2 GUI, it is possible to hide all the scare text away too
04:47nickchanand pressing a button to choosen an alternative boot volume is common on x86 as well so the power button long press don't count as scare
04:48JamesCalligeros[m]i dont think we can gui away all the kmutil scare text
04:49nickchani think it is possible as long as you make the user provide credentials in the gui
04:50nickchanJamesCalligeros[m]: imagine a custom Terminal app in recovery except you don't show the terminal UI
04:50nickchanno reason why kmutil can't be in a pseudo tty that the user never see
04:50JamesCalligeros[m]yeah, but then we'd have to either connect to the web and pull down the installer again or deposit n mib of dependencies in the apfs container instead of an n B shell script
04:54roxfan2 has joined #asahi-dev
05:01roxfan has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
05:10ddxtanx has joined #asahi-dev
05:55junefish has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
05:56junefish has joined #asahi-dev
06:06MichaelReeves[m]it could just be grab Mach-O from CDN / GitHub releases and then put it in the apfs container with the wheel script, which opens it
06:06JamesCalligeros[m]Yeah its not hard, its a matter of “do we want to do that”
06:07MichaelReeves[m]yeah. I feel like it could be cool but GUI stage one should be first
06:08MichaelReeves[m]also, did you get the just window screenshots I sent yesterday? I had bad wifi when I sent them so idk if it went through
06:11ddxtanx has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
06:15sobek[m]Also I feel that kmutil could be the sort of tool that’s meant not to take input from elsewhere.
06:15sobek[m]The scare text is scary but important.
06:27hello0092 has joined #asahi-dev
06:29svenTrue, and I’d rather not annoy Apple into locking down 1TR further because we hide the scary text
06:30bennofs3 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
06:30JamesCalligeros[m]Also for real if youre scared of pressing y on a tui… whatre you even doing here
06:31JamesCalligeros[m]imo our time would be better spent getting rid of the stupid curl | sh nonsense
06:31JamesCalligeros[m]Apple seem just about ready to ban it entirely anyway
06:32JamesCalligeros[m]Its been used in too many attacks for anyone reasonable to consider it a legitimate thing to do to your terminal now
06:33bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
06:34sobek[m]JamesCalligeros[m]: I really hate that `curl | sh`, I'm all in favour of seeing that vanish.
06:35MichaelReeves[m]Well IMO the only way to get rid of that would be notarisation, unless I’m missing something
06:36sobek[m]Hmm, I don't think we need notarization on scripts ?
06:36sobek[m](You could download an Asahi installer zip, extract it and run ./asahi.sh).
06:36sobek[m]Though a Gui would probably need a bundle, which wouldn need to be notarized.
06:37nickchanscripts can still get quarantine
06:37JamesCalligeros[m]You can just not notarise the app lol, adding a gatekeeper exception is common
06:37sobek[m](It could be nice to provide the user with the relevant data to check that the scary text apply to the Asahi install and not their main macOS install)
06:37JamesCalligeros[m]And like, its $99 a year…
06:37JamesCalligeros[m]Beats microslop’s code signing requirements
06:38MichaelReeves[m]Well chaos_princess was discussing the other day a GUI doesn’t nessecarily need a bundle, if it spins up a web page with python
06:38JamesCalligeros[m]That is the intention
06:38hardy94 has joined #asahi-dev
06:38MichaelReeves[m]Does SPI, Inc. have an Apple developer account ?
06:38sobek[m](And not to mention that right now, each Asahified distro tends to have its own installer, so you'd need to sign quite a few different installers)
06:38MichaelReeves[m]Cause it’s for the legal entity and it would have to be under them and not us
06:38JamesCalligeros[m]Not sure, but again its $99 a year if we absolutely must notarise then its not a big deal lol
06:39MichaelReeves[m]Like we couldn’t have it as “Asahi Linux” unless we made a seperate legal entity I think under apples rules
06:39sobek[m]There are options for FOSS entities to get the codesigning for free, if they aren't ever doing anything paid, though ?
06:39sobek[m]MichaelReeves[m]: Who is SPI Inc ?
06:40MichaelReeves[m]sobek[m]: “Software In the public interest Inc”
06:40JamesCalligeros[m]Software in the Public Interest
06:40chaos_princessMichaelReeves[m]: that's certainly a design.
06:40MichaelReeves[m]A NY 501(c)(3) that is asahis legal entity along with a bunch of other projects like Debian
06:40chadmedi dont think we need to get spi or oc involved or anything like that
06:41chadmedwe dont even really need to notarise it like i said
06:41chaos_princessi was thinking about more of something similar to the windows setup ui (yes, unironically)
06:41chadmedmacos folks are accustomed to just bypassing gatekeeper
06:41chadmedchaos_princess: me too lol
06:41chadmedthe new w11 winpe thing is actually not too bad tbqh
06:42sobek[m]chadmed: Apple is making it harder to bypass, and I really feel meh about each time I have to run xattr to drop the quarantine bit.
06:42chadmedyou cant just shift+click->open anymore?
06:42chadmedaaarrrghhhh
06:42chaos_princesshave to go into settings or sth
06:43chaos_princessi got annoyed enough to make an automator action that runs xattr -c
06:43sobek[m](You still have a GUI option hidden deep in the setting to allow an individual thing to run after getting the scary pop up "is damaged / dangerous, move to trash ?", or else, it is a terminal command. If we want to offer a GUI installer, this sort of thing defeats the purpose).
06:44sobek[m]chaos_princess: Ohh, perhaps I should do that ? Though on the other hand, there are few software that require me to do this dance.
06:44chaos_princessjust curlbash for now, worst case i will give 99 bucks to fruitco if it needs to happen
06:47chadmedi may or may not already be in the ADP
06:47chadmedso whatever
06:48chadmedits not an insurmountable hurdle and i dont care about 99 bucks
06:48chadmedcurl | sh is fine for now yes but we really should get rid of it at some point
06:52svenwhat’s so bad about curl|sh?
06:53MichaelReeves[m]it gives virus vibes and apple are probably going to block it in the near future given the exponential amount of fake CAPTCHA curl|sh viruses going around
06:53chaos_princessin our case - not that much except for vibes
06:53svenfair enough, I didn’t think about vibes
06:54chadmedtheyre getting antsy about it
06:54chadmedif your piped invocation looks sus terminal.app now shows a warning telling you piping stuff into sh is bad
06:54chadmedso yeah i really think theyre going to just make it stop working at some point
06:58chadmedalso re notarising other distros installers, meh
06:58chadmedthey shouldnt be modifying the installer's code really anyway, all the distro-specific stuff comes from the json blob
06:59chadmedthe nice thing about making it web based is we can just add a url parameter or something that tells the installer where to get the distro data from
07:03sven has quit [Quit: The Lounge - https://thelounge.chat]
07:03sven has joined #asahi-dev
07:09Jamie1 has quit [Quit: Bridge terminating on SIGTERM]
07:09rhysmdnz has quit [Quit: Bridge terminating on SIGTERM]
07:10hardy94 has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
07:14rhysmdnz has joined #asahi-dev
07:15Guest2476 has joined #asahi-dev
07:55aissen has quit [Quit: brb]
08:01chadmed has quit [Quit: Konversation terminated!]
08:03chadmed has joined #asahi-dev
08:14MichaelReeves[m]my IRL friend who's really good at art said she's gonna help me fix up the mockup so we're sorting it out now. I think the windows installer-like idea is really good so we'll see how that goes
08:16MichaelReeves[m]i kinda just showed it to her and then she was just "OMG no we need to fix this", so I guess programmers aren't the only people who can be nerd sniped
08:17chadmedthe way i see it youve got two options. either use the winpe installer look and feel or look at something like the autopilot pre-provisioning UX which might be a little friendlier and easier to implement sanely using webslop
08:17chadmeddont exactly copy the windows styles though, theyre ugly and gross
08:17chadmedits moreso the information layout and screen flow that is good
08:18chaos_princessthere are some copyable parts of windows style, at least it is much cleaner than the thing above
08:19chadmedi dont mind the way the winpe thingy looked for vista and the new windows 11 one is alright as well but the important things there are the flow of information and how it is laid out
08:19chadmedwe dont want shell32 icons
08:20chaos_princessis this enough of a "macos app" to use SF symbols?
08:21sobek[m]I'd say since this will necessarily be running on macOS, SF symbols and normal macOS fonts seem reasonable.
08:21sobek[m](Would the GUI be an alternative to the CLI, or a replacement ? (In the latter case, make sure to leave the CLI output visible ?))
08:21chaos_princessi am more concerned about the usage restrictions on sf symbols, you can only use it if you are a macos app, or a mockup of one
08:37MichaelReeves[m]OK is this kinda the right direction or not really (really early draft stage)?
08:38chaos_princessyep, that's more like it. the side graphics will need to change ofc, but looking good.
08:38sventhat looks quite nice
08:41dcavalca has joined #asahi-dev
08:41dcavalcaI like the idea of a generic installer that can ingest a branding config so that distros can use it without having to notarize their own build
08:42dcavalcaWe should also allow passing in a custom m1n1-stage1 so distros can still ship their own build if they want to do so
08:44JamesCalligeros[m]We can already do most of that with the installer_data.json
08:47chadmedand eventually this becomes less important as machines become useable upstream and the installer becomes "prep the machine for usb boot"
08:47chadmedprobably still a couple of years away from that being feasible though
08:47chaos_princessi like the "raspi flow" tbh
08:49myriaMichaelReeves[m]: is this for the website or the bundle plan?
08:49myriaI can write up a FastAPI for the installer if need be
08:50MichaelReeves[m]it could work either way for both plans imo
08:50chaos_princessif we do a .app, it will also be using the web view route
08:50chadmedchaos_princess: its convenient and easy for users but the fragmentation and "this is just a toy SBC" vibe is killing me
08:50leioI still think a web interface isn't a good fit, as it's more of a wizard alike flow in the CLI too, so you'd just be coding that kind of stuff in there, might as well just make the existing CLI steps programmatically better to read-write. Like how do you expose an API there that makes sense and isn't just shoehorning wizard progress contextual stuff assumptions in it
08:50chaos_princessjust throw up a webkit web view and go
08:50chadmedleio: the new cockpit-based anaconda works fantastically and thats just a webview
08:51chaos_princessleio: what is the problem writing a wizard flow with the web platform ui?
08:51leiosorry, I'm talking about how the CLI stuff remains and shares code; if the installer itself is a web interface, but the new backend part of it is what talks to such a wizard-like shared code with CLI, sure
08:51chadmedthe less garbage we have to bundle and distribute the better
08:51chaos_princessyes, the idea is to slightly refactor the existing installer so it can drive either the cli or some api thing
08:51chadmedthe existing installer would not be difficult to refactor into a backend core and a cli consumer of that core
08:51chadmedthere are only a few places where the UI is coupled to the logic
08:53leioif the installer is a web server that internally talks to the CLI stuff and exposes HTML that we can just show in safari, that's fine, I'm thinking of the parts for sharing code. Ultimately whoever does the work gets to pick what's best, I assume :)
08:53chaos_princessyes, that is kinda the plan (except not driving the cli as a cli, but just internal function calls in python)
08:54leioyeah, as long as the python code is refactored to be shared, so it's just different output modes of some kind or something, yeah
08:57chadmedok neat prospective v3 of macaudio works
08:57chadmedidk what to do about the pointer to the card struct though, i dont really want to completely change how the safety interlock works
09:01MichaelReeves[m]thoughts on taking inspiration from win 11 OOB (like the installer for the OS itself, not the app installers), it kinda does look really slick from google images but I'm not sure if it messes up the vibe we're going for
09:01chadmedthats what i meant by autopilot preprovision
09:01chadmedlike i said though, flow and layout only
09:02chadmedthe actual styling is gross
09:02chaos_princess08:41:11 <chaos_princess> i was thinking about more of something similar to the windows setup ui (yes, unironically)
09:02chaos_princessthough more from the pe part, as it is what does similar functions to the installer
09:04chadmedspecifically i like the "pick a windows edition" bit
09:05chaos_princess(pe is the part that runs as soon as you boot the iso, oobe is the "sign off your soul to msft" part that runs after the reboots)
09:05chadmedif we wanted to make that prettier you could lay out the list of distro options vertically on the left and put an infobox with some info and an image on the right
09:05leiofwiw, on second thought, it might be possible to nerdsnipe me into some appkit/swiftui thing if we are talking about own notarization anyways
09:06chaos_princessi think i mentioned it before, but being python allows us to ride on python's notarization
09:06chaos_princessand i am against riis/riiobj
09:09MichaelReeves[m]and against riih (Haskell?) /joking
09:10MichaelReeves[m]lowk would be fun though
09:10chadmedasahimonad
09:13MichaelReeves[m]ok we tried a more win 11 look, is that better or worse?
09:14chaos_princessdo a 1/3 2/3 split between logo and text
09:21aissen has joined #asahi-dev
09:24MichaelReeves[m]ooooh that looks good. thoughts - background or no background?
09:24chadmedsome accent graphics could be nice i suppose
09:24chadmedwe dont want to clutter it up tho
09:24MichaelReeves[m]sorry the images are lagging to upload
09:25MichaelReeves[m]here thats with background
09:25MichaelReeves[m]and then without
09:25chadmedyeah with is close to what i was thinking
09:25MichaelReeves[m]thats without now
09:25chadmedid get rid of the linebreak between room and for of course but thats all stuff thatll come out in the wash
09:25chadmedtheres a lot of negative space aorund the logo without some accent graphics
09:26MichaelReeves[m]I think keep graphics
09:26chadmedi would even block colour that panel
09:26chadmedlike a dark grey that accentuates the logo
09:26chadmedthe red we use looks better against dark
09:27MichaelReeves[m]block colour with graphics or without?
09:27chadmedwithout imo
09:27chadmeddark colour reduces the impact of negative space and allows the logo to stand out
09:27chadmedso we dont need to fill the void
09:33MichaelReeves[m]OMG YES that looks so good
09:34MichaelReeves[m]and then what can happen is downstream distress set the logo and accent colour in their JSON
09:34MichaelReeves[m]s/distress/distros
09:40hex86[m]holy shit
09:42MichaelReeves[m]ok so we're trying out the DE select screen now, not sure if its good. what do y'all think?
09:42chadmedthats pretty much exactly what i envisioned
09:43hex86[m]Out of curiosity, why not just use the base calamares installer?
09:43hex86[m]Ohh wait right yea it wouldn't necessarily run on macos 😅
09:44chadmedand because we already have all the infrastructure in python, we just need to slap a nice UI on top of it
09:45chaos_princessyep, looks good, ship it :P
09:45chaos_princessalthough would be kinda hard to get good hero images for minimal and uefi-only
09:46chadmedmeh they dont need them, the people selecting them know what a tty looks like
09:46MichaelReeves[m]UEFI-only could just be screenshot of U-boot
09:46chadmedor for f45, what kmscon looks like
09:46chaos_princessactually, for minimal do a *fetch
09:47chadmedoh yeah thats a neat idea
09:48chadmed(is this the worlds first instance of design by committee being effective)
09:48MichaelReeves[m]ok we're doing the partition page now, probably the hardest one to design right imo
09:48chadmedyeah this ones gonna be a bit shit
09:49chadmedi dont really like the slider idea from the first concept, it implies that you only get two partitions which is not necessarily the case
09:49chadmed"you might not have noticed it but your brain did"
09:53jannaucould use the cli path. either allow to install into free space or list apfs containers with enough free space and offer to resize them
09:54jannaucould have all partitions / free space in a selectable bar on top
09:58MichaelReeves[m]good idea, thanks!
09:58MichaelReeves[m]ok we'll prototype that
10:09MichaelReeves[m]omg its actually looking so good I dont believe this... we'll send it soon. artists are like MAGIC omg
10:17bgb has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
10:17bgb has joined #asahi-dev
10:17MichaelReeves[m]ok thoughts? maybe I was too hyped up about it before but I feel like its a good step forward but partitions are tricky so maybe it still has room for improvement
10:17MichaelReeves[m]basically you click the parts up the top to select where. if you do free space it says how much of the space do want to use? if you do APFS it says size for linux? and then for the ones you cant do (files in this scenario is exFAT) if you hover or click the (?) it says why
10:18chadmedenumerating all the possible reasons a partition may not be suitable is going to be tricky
10:19MichaelReeves[m]eh true. what should we do then?
10:19chadmedagain take inspo from the windows installer; "cant use this partition" is fine
10:19MichaelReeves[m]so just take away the tooltip?
10:19chadmedyeah pretty much
10:20MichaelReeves[m]thanks. do you think its good with that fixed or any other thoughts/feedback?
10:20jannauI wouldn't even list unsuitable partitions
10:20chadmedi would also change how free space is illustrated in the diagram. hatching/linework like that is usually a visual indicator for "cant be used"
10:21chadmedjannau: i think keeping them in the disk layout diagram is fair so that its obvious where partitions are on disk
10:21chadmedi would do what the macos installer does though and just dont even show them in the "select a volume" list
10:21kereru[m]MichaelReeves[m]: Looking good! Cool to see GUI installer being designed 😁 I think the first app page with dark background behind asahi logo would look a lot better if the bottom bar had a different background colour to the righthand 2/3 content area, what do you think?
10:21jannauin the diagram is fine and tooltip to display information about them would be welcome
10:22jannauI was speaking about the selection in the bottom part of the mockup
10:22chadmedyeah put the tooltip on hover over the diagram and just put "this volume cannot be used" or something like that
10:22chadmedand just dont list them in the radio button list
10:23MichaelReeves[m]thank you both for all that feedback, I think that sounds rly good, we'll try making v2 now
10:23MichaelReeves[m]kereru[m]: oh yes I do think that would look nicer, thank you for the suggestion! will try it now
10:30MichaelReeves[m]kereru: you were right, thank you! it looks much nicer
10:39MichaelReeves[m]ok here is partitions v2, showing what happens if you hover over files
10:39chadmedmuch better
10:40MichaelReeves[m]thanks! any further feedback or ready to move on to next screen?
10:41chaos_princessthere will be extra stuff on this page in case people have time machine, but this is for the future
10:42MichaelReeves[m]my friend is going to bed now, but im still shared into the design so ill try my best at the rest but it might be a bit shit lets see
10:46chadmed has quit [Quit: Konversation terminated!]
10:47chadmed has joined #asahi-dev
10:57MichaelReeves[m]ok here's the confirm screen. thoughts?
10:58chadmedyeaaahhh maybe wait for your mate to wake up tomorrow
10:58chadmedkidding, looks good
10:59chadmeddont know if the volume naming textbox belongs at the bottom of the page though. looks a bit unbalanced and out of place
10:59chadmedit should probably get its own screen, usually the final review/confirm screen should be readonly
11:00MichaelReeves[m]yeah true abt it being read only
11:01MichaelReeves[m]but I feel like a whole screen for the name is overkill?
11:01MichaelReeves[m]maybe integrate into partition screen or would that make it too busy?
11:01chaos_princessput it into the partitioning screen?
11:01chaos_princessto the right of the size field, there is space
11:02chadmedim going to say something that is probably controversial in 2026
11:02chadmedif you reduce the radius of the rounded corners, you will find that you can make the screens more information dense without impacting readability or flow
11:02chaos_princessalso, the current design already has enough space
11:03chaos_princessyou are targeting a desktop computer, those things have a mouse/trackpad, which allows precise control over the pointer
11:03chaos_princessdo not need to have a ton of empty space for the imprecision of touch controls
11:03chadmedand we can just set minimum dimensions, we know that ~all the screens these things are connected to will be at least 1080p
11:04yukaI have some commits for the t8140 dt: two formatting / dt-check-style related, and three for adding the pinctrl nodes as well as i2c dt-bindings and nodes. Should I make one series or two? and what do I write in the cover letter about the merge strategy for dt-bindings?
11:04yukapinctrl dt-bindings are already in the appropriate branch and iirc i2c dt-bindings can be merged via apple-soc?
11:04yukaso one series and merge everything through apple-soc is probably easiest?
11:04MichaelReeves[m]yeah true, thanks
11:05chaos_princessone is easiest, and yes, we can merge dt-only stuff via apple-soc as long as you have all the tags
11:06MichaelReeves[m]oh you were right, moving it works perfectly. here's both of them now
11:07chadmedon the confirmation screen, s/Name/Volume Name/ and move it to the top
11:07chadmedotherwise lgtm PR approved force push to main and tag release with no tests (y)
11:08chaos_princessyou need two more pages - the progress display and the 1tr entry guide
11:09MichaelReeves[m]i reckon I can raw dog 'em by just copying the UI elements she's already designed, lets see
11:09chaos_princessfor progress - progress bar and a dropdown that shows/hides console is fine
11:09chadmedi think the progress display can probably just echo back stdout/stderr to a terminal-like text area
11:09MichaelReeves[m]thoughts on "Did you know?" / fun fact and blog QR code or are they making it too busy
11:10chaos_princessentry guide will be kinda annoying to design without it becoming a wall of text
11:10chadmedprobably a bit wanky and corporate
11:10chaos_princessalso, why qr code?
11:10chadmeda small link to the blog is fine, doesnt need to be a QR code
11:10MichaelReeves[m]my thinking was if someones Mac is frozen from resizing they can get their phone and scan it
11:11chadmedchaos_princess: we can probably get some graphics made up? power button demonstration for each chassis type etc
11:11MichaelReeves[m]but yeah I think ur right, ill leave both out
11:13chaos_princesschadmed: don't wanna, next they gonna make a cylindrical mac mini and we will have to make new ones
11:13chadmedlmfao true, wall of text it is then
11:13chadmednot too concerned about that anyway, i like text
11:15chaos_princessbtw, what are y'all doing it in, figma?
11:15chadmedoh also small nit on the partitioning page, numbers should be right-aligned next to their unit
11:25MichaelReeves[m]ah, will fix that thx
11:25MichaelReeves[m]also, installing screen ready now, not too sure abt it. the image is sending rn
11:27chadmeds/It/Your Mac/ s/briefly//
11:28svenwow, that looks incredible. especially compared to the very first draft
11:29chadmedengineers can do a little UI design, as a treat
11:29chadmedonly under supervision though
11:42hello0092 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
11:43hello0092 has joined #asahi-dev
11:45MichaelReeves[m]thanks, subst applied
11:45MichaelReeves[m]now working on last screen, its hard to get right cause theres so much info to squeeze in
12:16MichaelReeves[m]done, ok tried my best but idkkkk
12:17beastd has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
12:17beastd has joined #asahi-dev
12:18chaos_princessits pretty good
12:19chaos_princesssome wording changes, - s/finish setting up/finalize installation/ or something
12:19chaos_princessthe point is that this is the first step
12:20chadmed"One last step" >lists three more steps >the three steps trigger "step 2"
12:20svenagreed, looks really nice!
12:21chadmedi would make the title "Finalise your installation"
12:21chaos_princessdo we want opt-in or opt-out for stats
12:21chaos_princessi'd prefer opt-out, but it feels a bit too corpo
12:21ants[m] has joined #asahi-dev
12:21ants[m]not a fan of "One last step", it sounds corpo like the Windows update screen bs
12:21chadmedand the subheading "Follow these steps to boot to Recovery Mode and finalise installation of Asahi Linux"
12:22chadmedalso re stats i would also prefer opt out but i know a lot of people are really sensitive to taht
12:22chadmedin the absence of opt out we should probably do a popover prompt for it rather than a hidden little checkbox
12:22chadmedwhen we click shut down maybe pop a prompt asking if to submit the stats
12:23jannaustats should not be opt-out. make it forced choice like the cli installer
12:23chadmedyeah which is what ^ is
12:23chaos_princessso, disable the "shut down" button choice and have a yes/no switch instead of a checkbox
12:23chaos_princess*disable before the user makes a choice
12:24chadmedi envision something more like user clicks shutdown, they are asked "would you like to submit blah blah blah", then the machine shuts down after they click yes or no
12:24chaos_princessnah, kind of a weird flow
12:25chaos_princessa button that says "shut down" should shut down, not pop up a screen
12:25jannaunot a fan of disabled buttons. Easier to have a separate screen where share stats have explicit "yes" / "no" choices
12:25svenstats should be either opt-in if it’s a checkbox or a yes/no choice
12:25chadmedok then yeah ask them to select yes/no then only show the shutdown button after that selection has been made
12:26chadmedi would also make the yes/no buttons modifiable up to the point that shut down is clicked
12:26MichaelReeves[m]thanks everyone for the great suggestions, doing it now
12:26chadmedi.e. store selected state in frontend and then the shutdown button actually submits the choice to the core and then initiates shutdown
12:26chadmedits a nicer ux than having the button be a one-and-done click
12:27francisssssssssretired[m] has joined #asahi-dev
12:28francisssssssssretired[m] is now known as francisssssssss[m]
12:33beastd|2 has joined #asahi-dev
12:35ants[m]what's up with the kerning?
12:35chaos_princesstool artifact i think, doesn't matter much at this point
12:35chadmed"Tip: Take a photo of this screen for reference"
12:35francisssssssss[m]hmmm, i'm a bystander on this mind, but wouldn't it be better to have this at the start? so in case something breaks, you'd be able to have consent to see what could have potentially gone wrong?
12:35chaos_princessnot what that thing sends
12:35chadmedotherwise looks great
12:36chaos_princessthe installer log is stored separately and not sent unless the user posts it
12:37beastd has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
12:38MichaelReeves[m]ah perfect, thank you
12:39MichaelReeves[m](just to show what its like when one's pressed)
12:39chaos_princesswe are doing en_AU? :P
12:40chadmedlmaoooo i was just thinking that
12:40chadmed(the answer is yes)
12:40chadmed(the real answer is we can just use localised strings)
12:40chaos_princess(at least it is not en_CHAOS, which is a bastard mix of en_GB and en_US)
12:40dcavalcaWe may want to make this localizeable if it's not too much hassle
12:40MichaelReeves[m]on a serious note, should we have actual i18n? I mean I'd be happy to do id-ID and many ppl here can do de-DE
12:41chaos_princesslet's have the infra in place, pulling strings out into a file is not hard
12:50bennofs3 has quit [Quit: Ping timeout (120 seconds)]
12:50bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
14:10kat[m] has left #asahi-dev [User left]
14:16bennofs3 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
14:21bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
14:39devdrago has joined #asahi-dev
14:47iwuvmika has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
14:49bgb has quit [Quit: WeeChat 4.10.1]
14:51sventhis looks very nice! thanks for those mockups!
14:54jvoisinfor the stats opt-in/opt-out dilemma, forcing the user to click on either "enable" or "disable" would ~solve the issue
14:54chaos_princessthats what we are going for
14:55jvoisinoh, it was lost in the backlog, my bad
15:01veloek has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
15:08veloek has joined #asahi-dev
15:09bennofs3 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
15:10meow676767676 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
15:28bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
15:30meow676767676 has joined #asahi-dev
15:36svenyay, my m5 MacBook just arrived. probably won't have any time today to see how hard it is to get the hv up there :(
15:51hardy94 has joined #asahi-dev
16:22WindowPain has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
16:40iwuvmika has joined #asahi-dev
16:48devdrago has quit [Quit: Connection closed for inactivity]
16:59devdrago has joined #asahi-dev
17:06iwuvmika has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
17:18hardy94 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
17:29hello0092 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
18:08___nick___ has joined #asahi-dev
18:08bennofs3 has quit [Quit: Ping timeout (120 seconds)]
18:08bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
18:15iwuvmika has joined #asahi-dev
18:41distantorigin has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
19:08devdrago has quit [Quit: Connection closed for inactivity]
19:16administratar[m]Should the new ui installer include an option for setting asahi as the default boot OS?
19:16administratar[m]Could be a default-checked checkbox with further instructions to set/change the default later
19:22chaos_princessinstaller already does it, and gui version will also do it, as it is a requirement for kmutil
19:30administratar[m]Alright, thanks for explaining! I didn't found it in the mockups, thats why I am asking.
19:30administratar[m](It seems I should read about kmutil as a newbie tomorrow)
19:30chadmed has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
19:30chadmed has joined #asahi-dev
19:30administratar[m]Or do I miss smth?
19:31chaos_princessit is mandatory, so there is no reason to make it an option
19:32administratar[m]Got it, thanks
19:32chaos_princesskmutil is the thing that among other features signs kernel images with this platform's equivalent of secureboot keys
19:54ConnorAlecks[m] is now known as Connor[m]
19:56junefish has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
19:58iwuvmika has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
20:01mulderje has left #asahi-dev [User left]
20:02junefish has joined #asahi-dev
20:03mulderje has joined #asahi-dev
20:05___nick___ has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
20:23elara has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
20:25___nick___ has joined #asahi-dev
20:31vimproved has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
20:32vimproved has joined #asahi-dev
20:44cow123 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
20:50bennofs3 has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
20:50hardy94 has joined #asahi-dev
20:59bennofs3 has joined #asahi-dev
21:00slowlydev has joined #asahi-dev
21:00slowlydev has quit []
21:07cow123 has joined #asahi-dev
21:28MichaelReeves[m]luckily I found there's all these "export to HTML" figma plugins so I won't have to raw dog it when trying to replicate the design (which I dont think im good enough at web dev to do)
21:28MichaelReeves[m]one of them actually generates really nice looking code but im suspicious its using a clanker to do it so ill have to look into it more
21:29hardy94 has quit [Remote host closed the connection]
21:29JamesCalligeros[m]Id prefer hand rolling it even if it takes longer and is not as good
21:29JamesCalligeros[m]But look at the state of my website, my opinions dont count
21:36beastd|2hand rolling should win out over time (all things can still go wrong for all reasons of course)
21:36beastd|2 is now known as beastd
21:41yurix has quit [Read error: Connection reset by peer]
21:43yurix has joined #asahi-dev
22:12MichaelReeves[m]well I dont even have a website so mine count even less lol :D
22:12MichaelReeves[m]but I looked into some of the CSS flex box stuff and it seems it wouldn't actually be too bad to hand roll, so im going to try now
22:12MichaelReeves[m]I think it should be possible to get pretty close
22:12JamesCalligeros[m]yeah its not hard its just tedious
22:13yurix_ has joined #asahi-dev
22:13chaos_princessthankfully, bootstrap exists
22:16yurix has quit [Ping timeout: 480 seconds]
22:17yurix_ is now known as yurix
23:41MichaelReeves[m]ooh im actually not as bad at this as I thought
23:41MichaelReeves[m]first screen done now and it looks 99% the same
23:41MichaelReeves[m]helpfully figma provides like a tab on each component that shows you the CSS properties u need
23:42MichaelReeves[m]i also pushed it with cloudflare so you can see it https://gui-installer-html.rexapi.workers.dev/
23:42MichaelReeves[m]anyway ill work on the 2nd one now
23:43MichaelReeves[m]any feedback if it doesnt look right is appreciated
23:46JamesCalligeros[m]ugh even as someone who writes javascript every day i forgot how disgusting and putrid frontend DOM manipulation type javascript is
23:55JamesCalligeros[m]i would not fix the css elements to a pixel size themselves
23:55JamesCalligeros[m]fix the viewport then use rem/em for the elements inside the viewport
23:55JamesCalligeros[m]otherwise youre going to have problems with os level scaling
23:59iwuvmika has joined #asahi-dev
…